Montclair's two library buildings are going to close at the same time. Before that happens, residents have a short window to shape two things: the finished buildings and the years without them. On Oct. 19, the Montclair Public Library's Board of Trustees picked DIG Architecture, out of 21 firms that applied, to design a renovation and expansion of the Main Library on South Fullerton Avenue and the Bellevue Avenue Branch. That is how Montclair Local reported it. Library Director Radwa Ali told patrons, "We are now officially moving from planning into design."
The state funding behind the project has already decided most of what the new buildings will hold. Two decisions are still open. One is where those spaces go inside each building. The other is what library service looks like during the stretch when neither building is open to the public.
The state money has already set the room list
On its renovation page, the library puts the total project cost at $37,327,219. The New Jersey Economic Development Authority's Cultural Arts Facilities Expansion Program, known as CAFE, is covering $36,661,719 of it, and the Township's contribution is estimated at about $8 million. The Township figure includes $5 million the council approved in 2025 for urgent repairs and never spent. Montclair Local covered that vote in March 2025, listing Main Library HVAC, roof, solar and window work, plus water remediation and courtyard restoration at Bellevue.
The award came with a program attached. The NJEDA's June 2026 announcement lays out the Main Library floor by floor.
| Main Library | Bellevue Avenue Branch | |
|---|---|---|
| Built | 1955, last overhauled 1996 | 1914, a Carnegie library |
| Scope | Full gut renovation of three floors and basement | Restoration of the historic building plus a two-story addition of about 5,600 square feet |
| Access | Entrance relocated and made fully accessible | New ground-level entrance on the Norwood Avenue side with an elevator to every level |
| Building systems | New mechanical, electrical and plumbing, new roof with rooftop solar, insulated windows | HVAC and lighting upgrades, access control, water infiltration remediation, façade restoration |
| Named spaces | Teaching kitchen, commons, auditorium, galleries, terrace, FabLab, Jazz Library, classrooms, youth STEAM space, media studios, sensory room | Multipurpose community room, teen room, children's room, classrooms, redesigned front plaza |
At Bellevue, the addition more than doubles the building's size. According to the library's request for proposals, the Norwood Avenue side is the only location where an ADA-accessible entrance is feasible. The library's own page calls that entrance and elevator the branch's first full accessibility.
The Main Library is about 49,000 square feet. The RFP describes building systems at the end of their life, original 1950s windows, a roof that needs replacing and an entrance that does not meet current accessibility standards.
What the design can still move
The RFP leaves more room for change than the room list suggests. The CAFE-required program spaces are fixed. Their locations, sizes, configurations and arrangement across floors can still change during design, and the 2025 concept plans are described as a starting point, not a fixed blueprint. The floor-by-floor layout in the state's announcement is a description of the plan so far. Where the FabLab ends up relative to the children's spaces, or how the teaching kitchen relates to the auditorium, is the kind of decision DIG Architecture will make in the coming months.
The RFP also sets out which parts of the Main Library's character must survive:
- The curved front façade keeps its curve. The heavily divided windows inside it are meant to be redesigned to let in far more daylight, possibly with ground-level glass doors that let the building open along its front for events.
- The cylindrical tower running through all three floors stays and should be enhanced. The library asked the design team to study widening it to make room for a working café and kitchen.
- The front portico gets rebuilt. Since the main entrance is moving, the new portico becomes the roof over an outdoor stage, wired for lighting, sound and power, at the center of a redesigned front plaza.
- The main staircase is called "one of the Main Library's signature features." The RFP says the stair can be relocated, reconfigured or rebuilt to meet code, as long as it remains the building's central architectural moment.
The staircase is where earlier coverage and the current plan part ways. In June, Montclair Local reported that the stairwell would be restored. The RFP, issued in July, gives the architect permission to rethink it entirely. If the stair matters to you, the listening sessions are the time to say so.
At Bellevue, the room for change is narrower. The work must meet the Secretary of the Interior's Standards and go through historic review. The classical façade, arched windows, brick and limestone construction, high ceilings and original woodwork are all treated as historic fabric to be preserved.
Why both buildings close at the same time
The schedule comes from the funding. The library's FAQ says NJEDA's four-year construction deadline starts when the award agreement is signed, and that "the library and Township cannot extend it on their own." The same answer explains, "This is why both buildings close at the same time and construction runs concurrently." The RFP expects the agreement to be signed within roughly six months of the June 10, 2026 approval. Both buildings must receive temporary certificates of occupancy before the four years run out.
The library's published timeline has design and planning in 2026, construction starting at both locations in 2027, and reopening in 2030. The FAQ narrows the reopening target to early 2030 and says plainly that "construction will require closing the buildings to the public, though the exact timing and sequence are still being worked out." The June coverage projected completion in 2029. The current materials say 2030, because the clock starts when the agreement is signed, not when the award was announced.
No temporary location has been named. The RFP says only that the library will use temporary and satellite service strategies while both buildings are closed. In June, Ali told Montclair Local, "We do not intend to stop serving the public during that time." She said the library was looking for community partners to provide temporary space for staff and collections.
Bellevue has been closed before
The interim plan carries extra weight at Bellevue because the branch has a history of closing. A 2010 Patch report found Bellevue open just one day a week after budget cuts, and a resident quoted in the story said community leaders had beaten back closure attempts in 1977 and 1989. According to a 2017 Montclair Local story, the branch closed briefly in 2010 and reopened a few years later. The library said then that it planned to seek state bond money for work at both buildings, including ADA access at Bellevue.
That money never came. In March 2025, Ali told Montclair Local that Montclair had "missed our shot back in 2020" at Library Construction Bond Act funding, and described CAFE as a second chance.
This closure is different from the earlier ones. It has a deadline and a reopening built in, and it ends with an accessible entrance that Bellevue has never had. The open question is how the neighborhood around Bellevue Avenue gets service in the meantime.
Where your input goes now
The library is asking about the gap directly. Question 47 of the Main Library Space & Collections Survey says the building "will be partly/fully closed for a stretch" during the 2027–2030 renovation and asks what residents would most need kept running. The survey also asks where a temporary pop-up library would be convenient. The Bellevue survey asks the same two questions about that branch. The Main survey also asks which new spaces people would actually use, what would bring someone to the auditorium on a weeknight, and whether the teaching kitchen should host cooking classes, heritage food demos or simply be "a good café to sit & work."
Each survey takes about 15 minutes. For every 100 submissions, the library draws a $50 Watchung Booksellers gift card. The surveys opened in June and list no closing date. The renovation page also has an open-ended feedback form where contact details are optional.
Ali is hosting the in-person listening sessions herself. "No preparation and no expertise required," she wrote, according to Montclair Local. Four sessions remain, all at the Main Library:
- Thursday, Nov. 5, 10 a.m. to noon, Classroom, first floor
- Friday, Nov. 6, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., Tower Room, second floor
- Sunday, Nov. 8, 1:30 to 3:30 p.m., Teen Room, first floor
- Sunday, Nov. 8, 3:30 to 5:30 p.m., Teen Room, first floor
Space is limited and registration is required through the library's event calendar.
Projects like this one change what a block feels like for years, from a gut renovation on South Fullerton Avenue to a historic branch doubling in size on Bellevue Avenue. If you own near either library and want to know how the construction years and the reopening could affect your home's value, Joseph Simone is glad to talk it through. Request a free home valuation and local market consultation.